Welcome to my personal blog. I mostly write on entrepreneurship, economics, libertarianism, movies, and my travels.

Search This Blog

Feb 18, 2013

Top 10 Most Popular Nepali Blogs


 I recently wrote a news article about the rise of social media in Nepal. While writing the news I had tried to find out the total number of active blogs in Nepal but to no avail. Even finding out the estimate was a tough job. Then, I wondered, so what are the most popular blogs of Nepal. There wasn't any definite list but Alexa.com provided a list of most popular websites of Nepal which included a few blogs.

So, from the data provided by alexa.com, I have compiled the top 10 most popular Nepali blogs. 

Rank among Nepali Websites: 28
Overall Rank in Alexa: 43,258

Started by Salokya in April 2005, it is one of the first blogs in Nepali Unicode and currently the most popular Nepali blog. Mainly focused on current issues, it covers the major political, economic and social happenings of Nepal. The site has received more than 48 million visitors till date.

Rank among Nepali Websites: 86
Overall Rank in Alexa: 75,645

Contains news, views and reviews of Nepali movies and artists. The site claims to have more than 20,000 unique visitors everyday.

Rank among Nepali Websites:193
Overall Rank in Alexa: 333,316

Run by Web developer Ashesh Shrestha, the blog is very popular Nepalese for its utilities like Nepali Calendar, Nepali Unicode and date converter. Blogposts are mainly related to information technology and social media.

Rank among Nepali Websites:276
Overall Rank in Alexa: 703,260

The blog for football enthusiasts of Nepal. Posts are about league matches, football clubs as well as football players of Nepal.

Rank among Nepali Websites:332
Overall Rank in Alexa: 350,989

It is one of the most ubiquitous blogs in the Nepalese blogging scenario. Started by Anil Ghimire, a Computer Software Engineer in 2007, the blog currently has several contributors posting mainly about current happenings as well as socio-political issues of Nepal. Recordings of literary radio programs are one of the most popular postings in the blog.

Rank among Nepali Websites:422
Overall Rank in Alexa: 58,906

Personal blog of Mukesh Chapagain, a PHP Magento Programmer and computer Engineer from Nepal. Posts are mainly about php programming and open source software like Ubuntu.

Rank among Nepali Websites:625
Overall Rank in Alexa: 653,119

Run by Pradeep Kumar Singh, a Nepalese student in United Kingdom, the blog "wants to be developed as a community blogging, a community blog that wants a peaceful and democratic Nepal." Posts are mainly about current happenings about Nepal.

Rank among Nepali Websites:1316
Overall Rank in Alexa: 860,467

Personal blog of Lex Limbu, a non-resident Nepali student blogger based in the United Kingdom. Blog posts are mainly about entertainment industry of Nepal, i.e. movies, music, fashion.

 Rank among Nepali Websites:1364
Overall Rank in Alexa:150,748

The blog of Nirmal Gyanwali, a front-end web developer based in Sydney, Australia. Started as a personal blog, the blog currently has several contributors. Posts are mainly about information technology.

 Rank among Nepali Websites:2409
Overall Rank in Alexa:1,576, 750

Personal blog of Janak Raj Bhatta, Assistant IT Administrator of National Human Rights Commission of Nepal. As mentioned in the site, the author blogs for "sharing thoughts, raising voice for voiceless and some some stories for fun causes."

Did I miss a more popular blog? Please share in the comments below!

Feb 10, 2013

Dalit Capitalism for Nepal


Despite the almost universal acceptance of free markets as the most superior system for economic growth and prosperity around the world, the concept does not resonate well with policymakers and public intellectuals of Nepal.In this context, free market as a means of social transformation may sound like a paradox but that is precisely what it is. An example from Nepal can shed light on this phenomenon.

Going by the law

Caste-based discrimination is arguably the worst social evil facing Nepali society today. Although it was officially abolished in 1963, the problem persists and is prevalent across the nation, especially in remote parts. Oppressed castes have been historically denied access to decision-making as well as power sharing. The untouchable castes are estimated to be around 15 per cent of the total population and almost half of them are below the poverty line, which is much higher when compared to the national poverty rate of 25.16 per cent. The government has passed the Caste-based Discrimination and Unaccountability Act 2011 to prohibit caste-based discrimination in both public and private spheres but the effectiveness of the law to prevent such practices is yet to be seen.

As long as these people languish in poverty and are economically dependent on people of 'higher castes', people of lower castes will have a hard time trusting legal remedies as a recourse for their ailments. Letting the socially oppressed economically empower themselves by encouraging them to participate in the market process, however, can be an effective way of discouraging discrimination. As Nobel Laureate Economist, Milton Friedman once said, “The great virtue of a free market system is that it does not care what colour people are; it does not care what their religion is; it only cares whether they can produce something you want to buy. It is the most effective system we have discovered to enable people who hate one another to deal with one another and help one another.” Thus free market is an antidote to discrimination based on caste or other ascribed values rather than merit. 

Changing scenario

In fact, this transformation is in progress in many rural parts of the country. Foreign employment, which is estimated to be engaging more than three million Nepali workers already, has been a popular source of economic empowerment for people of oppressed castes who find little or no employment opportunities outside their traditional jobs in the current social system of Nepal. “As dalits have started to go abroad, they have started getting richer and more confident about their rights. And in many cases, people of higher castes have started to become financially dependent on them for loans and borrowings. In such a scenario, it is undesirable and difficult to discriminate against dalits,” a school teacher from Hodaa village of Kalikot district told this scribe during a visit to the region.

Such economic empowerment can be a more sustainable solution to the problem of caste-based discrimination than enactment of new laws or use of force to change people’s behaviours. Similarly, development of entrepreneurship among dalits within the country is also contributing significantly in their empowerment. A study titled Social Inclusion of Dalits through Micro-enterprise included in Micro-enterprises Development for Poverty Alleviation report by Ministry of Industry notes that 83 per cent of dalits engaged in entrepreneurial activities in Nawalparasi district have started getting respect from non-dalits, whereas 28 per cent of them have started approaching police, courts, local groups and government offices as compared to just nine per cent in the past.

Practical and effective

The idea that free markets are beneficial to oppressed castes has been corroborated by India’s experience since the economic reforms of 1991. Chandrabhan Prasad, a well known anthropologist and dalit activist in India, has termed the transformation of dalit people of India after the economic reform as ‘dalit capitalism’. In his study titled Market and Manu: Economic Reforms and its Impact on Caste in India, he argues, “The market has the potential for neutralizing caste in India’s public life and finally leading India into a caste-free zone. Unlike the State, the market operates from within caste society, as an internal force, and hence has the inherent capacity to rip apart the very fabric of the caste order.” And much to the credit of his hypothesis, Dalit Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industry which was formed in 2005, now boasts of more than 1,000 dalit entrepreneurs as members, majority of whom were able to embark on their entrepreneurial journey after the economic reforms of the early 1990s.

Hence, liberalization and market-oriented economic reforms could be a more practical and effective solution to one of our worst social evils. Unlike the picture painted by politicians and public intellectuals about markets, as demonstrated by the case of India, free market whose main value system is merit rather than caste, can be a perfect antidote to the unfair value system created by the caste system.

--Surath Giri

Jan 21, 2013

Top 10 of the Books I Read in 2012


Last year I was able to read only 16 books, less than half of the initial target of 40 books.It lesser than the number of books I had read in 2011 (25 books). I guess, as you get more engulfed into your professional life, reading becomes more of a luxury than an essential part of life. But I am happy that I  was able to read some very important books during the year. Following are the Top 10 of the books I read in 2012 (Not in any particular order):

1. Steve Jobs: A Biography by Walter Issacson

My first reading of 2012 was this 600-pages official biography of Steve Jobs by Water Issacson. Very few things remain to be said about this legendary but highly controversial character who wanted to “put a dent in the universe” and is among the handfuls who actually did. Famous for revolutionizing PC industry, music industry, movie industry and cell-phone industry and infamous for his condescending attitude and treatment towards  his employees, family, friends, business counterparts and practically everyone, Jobs was truly a multidimensional and complex character who lived through one after another dramatic phases in his life. This biography is a must read if you have ever been impressed by Steve Jobs or his inventions in your life or want to know an honest account of the life of a visionary. I found the book very comprehensive, brutally honest and very interesting to read.

2. Fatalism and Development: Nepal's Struggle for Modernization by Dor Bahadur Bista

If you ask me, this is probably the most cited Nepali book till date. I was impatient to read this book after I had too many of "OMG, you haven't read Fatalism and Development yet?" reactions from people during conversations about books. So it was among the first book I read in 2012. Written by the renowned sociologist Dor Bahadur  Bista and published in 1991, even after two decades the book is still very relevant and resourceful for anyone wishing to understand the cultural and social aspects of Nepalese society that prevents it from fully modernizing. He has described how Nepali society has been engineered into a fatalistic attitude mainly because of 'alien' influence of Brahmanism from India. At times, I found his generalizations about castes and ethnic groups too uncomfortable but overall the insights he provides are very useful.

I have written an article on the relationship between Fatalism and Free Market which can be found here.

3. Innovation and Entrepreneurship: Practice and Principles by Peter F. Drucker

In this classic book, Drucker describes about the difference between entrepreneurship and business. The difference between the two terms is very confused, especially in the developing societies where innovation is lower compared to more developed societies. Drucker says entrepreneurship is more about innovation than just a business. Innovation doesn't necessarily mean finding a new product or technology only, innovation is, in fact in most cases, about finding new ways of doing the same thing more effectively, recognizing the incongruity between the perception of consumers and producers, recognizing the changes in industry and market structure and adjusting products and services accordingly, planning and producing products and services according to the demographic structures of the society etc.

You can read more of my thoughts on the book here.

4. Keynes Hayek: The Clash that Defined Modern Economics by Nicholas Wapshott

I very much enjoyed this book — which is detailed and entertaining and conceptual all at once. The book basically outlines, the lives, works, influences and inter-relationship of two great economists of the twentieth century- F.A. Hayek and J.M. Keynes whose opposing and conflicting view points competed to dominate the political economic discourses of the world for the past century and continue to do so. Keynes,a proponent of government intervention and direction of the economy was able to dominate the discourse until 1970s whereas Hayek, a proponent of free markets dominated the scene from 1970s to 2008 as per the author.

It is hard to find anyone who hasn't heard about J.M. Keynes and it is hard to find many people who have heard about F.A. Hayek, let alone people who have actually read his books. But it is very interesting to know that these two people with competing claims have influenced the political economic discourse of the past century so much. You can read more of my thoughts on the book here.

5. The Millionaire Next Door by Thomas J. Stanley and William D. Danko

No, the book is NOT about how to become a millionaire. There are countless books that promise to make you a millionaire and if reading made someone a millionaire I would be surely among the first ones ;) . Based on years on research, statistics and case studies, this book profiles people who are already millionaires and tries to find the common traits and behaviours (especially saving and spending behaviour) between them.

One of the major findings of the study is that high-income-earners with a hyper-consumer lifestyle are not necessarily millionaires. Majority of the wealthy people are those high-earners with a frugal mindset. Majority of the millionaires were found to be living below their means, allocating time and resources for things that help build wealth (e.g. good education), giving more importance to financial independence than display of social status and making their adult children financially independent. Most interestingly, 80% of these wealthy people created the wealth themselves not inherited it. Although, the book is based on American millionaires, the insights it provides are universally applicable. But let me warn you: the book is quite boring and repetitive at times.

6. The Big Three in  Economics by Mark Skousen

A very well-written and easy to read (easy to listen for me) book, The Big Three in Economics describes the battle of ideas among the three most influential economists in world history: Adam Smith, representing laissez faire; Karl Marx, reflecting the radical socialist model; and John Maynard Keynes, symbolizing big government and the welfare state. The author not only describes the ideas proposed by these personalities but also highlights the lives they led. The author is obviously an admirer of Adam Smith and makes no efforts to hide it. He has put Smith on the top rung of the totem pole of influence and impact followed by J.M. Keynes and Karl Marx at the bottom. However, he has his opinions well backed up by the facts and observations. I found the book very insightful, entertaining and informative.

7.  Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Korea by Barbara Demick

I accidentally started reading this book. One day while going through my e-library in my laptop I found this book. So, I read a few pages to see if it was interesting enough. Then I could not stop before finishing it. In this moving book, journalist Barbara Demick follows the lives of six North Koreans of various walks of life who have fled North Korea and are currently living in South Korea, to find out what it's like to live as an ordinary citizen in the 'Hermit Kingdom'. The lives of ordinary people seems as if they are living in an Orwellian world, probably even worse. It is hard not to get emotional while reading the book, feel pity for ordinary North Koreans and be thankful that you were not born there.

I have written a blog-post detailing the 13 most shocking things I found about ordinary people's lives in North Korea in this book. You can read them here.

8. A Kingdom Under Siege: Nepal's Maoist Insurgency, 1996 to 2004 by Deepak Thapa

A journalistic account of social, political history of Nepal as a background to the Maoist Insurgency that engulfed Nepal for a decade. The book covers the events of until 2004 only when the Maoist insurgents and the government declared siege fire for the second time and sat down for talks. Thapa vividly describes the way people's lives had been affected by the insurgency, the motivations that drove the insurgents and the way government reacted to the phenomenon. It is a very informative and insightful book for anyone wishing to understand the causes and effects of the insurgency in Nepal. I wish the author would write another book detailing the events of post 2004 until the movement of 2006 that ended the insurgency with a peace agreement.



9.  The Elusive Quest for Growth: Economists' Adventures and Misadventures in the Tropics by William Easterly

I had read a few chapters of this book before and have written about this book a few times in my blog as well. But this year, I read the book cover to cover. This is one of the most important books I have read about development economics. In this book, Easterly describes why the numerous efforts to improve the lives of people living in Third World countries have failed and what can be done to achieve the real result. Recently, i saw an article by Oxfam saying "Annual income of richest 100 people enough to end global poverty four times over". People talk as if developing countries have not received any aid at all till date. How I wish people would read this book and realize that the problem of poverty is not that there in not enough aid or not that wealth is concentrated. The major problem is how majority of the people in Third World countries are deprived from creating wealth. 

10. Banker to the Poor: Micro-Lending and the Battle Against World Poverty by Muhammad Yunus

I had heard a lot about Grameen Bank and micro-credit before but did not actually know the nitty-gritty and inspiration behind the program. This autobiography of Yunus describes how the idea of Grameen Bank was born and how micro-credit has been helping millions of poor around the world. Yunus has also described how Grameen Bank have adapted with the social and economic backgrounds of its clients to develop the current mechanism of providing micro-credit which tries to encompass as many poor as possible along with addressing not only the economic challenges faced by them but also the social challenges. Grameen Bank maintains a repayment rate of around 97% and has a net worth of more than a billion dollars. The book provides insights to the readers on how poor are capable of helping themselves and how helping them help themselves is more effective than patronizing them with charity.

So, that was the list of top ten of the books I read in 2012. What do you think? How many of them have you read? Are there any books that you would recommend me based on my interest as depicted in this list? Do share feedback and opinions in the comments below!

(Published by Vibes magazine in its 1st Anniversary Special Issue of May 2013.)

Jan 19, 2013

Institutions versus Collaborations: How the media landscape is changing


I am a big admirer of Clay Shirky and his works on social and economic effects of internet technologies, especially social media. I have read both of his books "Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing without Organizations" and "Cognitive Surplus: Creativity and Generosity in a Connected Age" and written a few words about them. Today, I stumbled across this TED Talk by him in which he talks about how the rise of information communication technology, especially the social media is transforming the landscape of media itself. 

He argues that as more and more people are becoming both producers and consumers of information unlike in the past where majority of people were supposed to be just consumers consuming the information produced and disseminated by a smaller group of professionals; closed groups and companies will slowly disappear giving way for smaller, independent and more dynamic groups and individuals. The rigid and somewhat central planning is becoming inept to compete with the flexible and responsive coordination between individuals.


This talk so reminded me of another video called I,Pencil which describes how millions of people from different parts of the world, belonging to different culture, race and religion coordinate and collaborate with each other in the free market and produce value for each other. The coordination present in the market is impossible to be replicated by central planning.


 
 
What do you think? Do share your views and opinions in the comments below!

Jan 11, 2013

Why Good Politics is Bad Economics


People, normally tend to think of government as a self-less and benevolent entity looking out for the overall interest of the public. Public choice theory which studies the relationship between politics and economics , however suggests that various actors that interact in the political market-place such as politicians, bureaucrats, special interest groups have their own self-interest to cater to.

Politics is also full of people with their self-interest. For eg politicians are interested in securing power, bureaucrats are looking for more money, special interest groups seeking subsidies and protection from competition etc. Hence, such interactions usually result in policies and decisions that make general public worse off.

Along with my friend, I have made a video on this issue with an example from Nepal. We have taken the performance of state-owned enterprises and their continued existence despite their huge losses and decline in relevance as an example of such interaction.


We made this video for an international video contest being organized by The Fraser Institute, a think tank from Canada. Besides the Jury Awards, there is an additional award called 'Viewer's Choice Award' which is given to the video entry with the highest number of likes in Youtube.

So, please watch our video, hit like in YouTube (if you like the video that is) and share it and help us win the award.

Thank you for your support!

Dec 17, 2012

Growing Enterprises in Nepal


Since the fall of Soviet Union and dire performance of centrally planned economies, the world in general is moving towards open and market economies. The trend is highlighted by the increasing economic freedom around the world. According to the Economic Freedom of the World Report, the average economic freedom score of the world in 1980 was 5.30 which has ever since increased steadily to 6.83 in 2010. One of the important aspects of a market based economy is the crucial role entrepreneurs and private sector play in the economic growth and development. Entrepreneurship is slowly getting the recognition it deserves for its role in among other things, poverty alleviation. United Nations' Commission on the Private Sector and Development has acknowledged that “the private sector can alleviate poverty by contributing to economic  growth, job creation and poor people’s incomes. It can also empower poor people by providing a broad range of products and services at lower prices.”

According to Global Entrepreneurship Monitor which makes an annual assessment of the entrepreneurial activity worldwide, India and China alone are home to more than 200 million small firm owners and entrepreneurs currently. India is said to be already enjoying the third wave of entrepreneurship that has transcended the national boundaries and vying for international supremacy. Prior to the reforms of early 1990s, in their first wave of entrepreneurship, Indian entrepreneurs were busy fighting the bottlenecks, regulations and limits as well as other non-political hurdles and had limited impact in the economy.

Unfortunately, Nepal till date seems to be caught up in that particular phase. Entrepreneurship as a means of poverty alleviation and economic growth as of now does not resonate well with the government, intelligentsia and the development sector of Nepal. So it should not come as a surprise that major employment programs of the government are focused on providing employment or equipping people with 'marketable' skills which is supposed to them a better employee but not necessarily a job creator.

However, with a comparatively lesser amount of resources more jobs could be created through fostering entrepreneurship in Nepal. An estimated 400,000 people enter the job market in Nepal annually and very few of them have the idea of starting their own venture on their mind. As observed around the world and in case of Nepal too, entrepreneurship development requires more than just a program and more than just one of the actors of the society. To create a sustainable environment for fostering entrepreneurship and reaching out to a wide range of the populace, there is a necessity to create an entrepreneurial ecosystem which can support aspiring entrepreneurs in every step of their entrepreneurial journey. Addressing just one aspect of the entrepreneurial ecosystem is likely to end up in failure. E.g. Even if the government's Youth Self-Employment Fund had been implemented as intended, it would have ended up in failure because it seemingly addressed only one aspect of entrepreneurship- access to capital.

So what constitutes an entrepreneurial ecosystem and how can it be built? The first step to building an entrepreneurial ecosystem would be finding ways to tackle the stigma held by our society towards entrepreneurship and profit-making. Society's attitude towards business and profit-making as immoral and tantamount to cheating and robbing people can be a self-fulfilling prophecy and encourage the already pervasive crony capitalism in Nepal that has been benefiting a few at the cost of many. Values of entrepreneurship and innovation can be instilled in the students by introducing entrepreneurship in the curriculum from school level. Lack of any encounter with the idea of entrepreneurship during school curriculum has resulted in students seeking good employment as career goals rather than starting a venture on their own. Although a few educational institutions like King's College have started entrepreneurship in the syllabus of their tertiary level education, and few organizations like Samriddhi, The Prosperity Foundation have been running courses on entrepreneurship that focuses on introducing the concept of entrepreneurship to university level students, there is a need to introduce the concept in younger levels too.

Next, in the entrepreneurial ecosystem is the access to capital and mentorship required for aspiring entrepreneurs. Venues for aspiring entrepreneurs to pitch their ideas and acquire necessary funding, to network with other entrepreneurs working in similar fields and practical suggestions and guidelines from a more experienced entrepreneur or leader have to be created to turn the ideas of entrepreneurship into reality. Private sector, especially non-governmental organizations and even self-help styled groups that aspiring entrepreneurs can form on their own can achieve this step in the ecosystem. The rising popularity of interaction and story sharing programs like Entrepreneur for Nepal's Last Thursdays with an Entrepreneur shows that there is huge demand for such initiatives. Similarly, Biruwa Ventures, an attempt by 3 Nepali students to adopt the model of venture capitalism and provide support mechanism for aspiring entrepreneurs is getting wide appreciation. The concept of mentorship of young aspiring entrepreneurs by well-established entrepreneurs is slowly getting popular. Entrepreneurs for Nepal, a loosely connected group of entrepreneurs of Nepal has been providing avenues for such mentorship through its sounding board and boot camp programs. It is high time that programs like these be replicated across the nation, especially other cities and major economic areas. Development organizations working in economic development and livelihood issues can play a vital role in getting these programs across the country and have a larger impact.

Entrepreneurial journey does not stop here. Expansion and sustainability of the business venture that comes next is a crucial step for ensuring that businesses have a significant impact in the society through  creation of long term job opportunities and capital formation. Commercial banks play a major role in this step. Financial institutions as of now are not eager to invest in areas outside of their traditional domains and businesses outside the well-established business houses although a few banks like Mega Bank have come up with loan mechanisms for aspiring small scale ventures.

Government and civil society should also start focusing on recognizing entrepreneurs for their contribution in the economy and nation's prosperity. The recently concluded Global Entrepreneurship Week which had 35000 activities being organized around the world bringing message of entrepreneurship across to more than 7 million participants in  130 countries including Nepal is one such platform. Similarly, increasing recognition of social entrepreneurs and their contribution in solving society's problems can be harnessed by complimenting such efforts with efforts from government as well.

Last but not the least important aspect of entrepreneurship development is the policy regime of a country. Regulatory hurdles, corruption, political intervention in the economy has made Nepal one of the toughest countries to do business. The poor performance of Nepal is the Doing Business Report is a well-known fact for our private sector as well as policymakers. Being the domain of the government, policy reforms and business environment enhancements have to be carried out by the government. The government's priority should be on how to create a nation of entrepreneurs rather than a nation of job-seekers or providing employment to everyone.

-Surath Giri

Nov 30, 2012

Moral Criticisms of Capitalism: Paul Heyne's Thoughts!


Paul Heyne
Yesterday I stumbled upon a lecture titled 'The Moral Critics of Capitalism' by Paul Heyne. It's a shame that I had never heard of him before. Paul Heyne, as I have come to know now, is the author of the acclaimed textbook "The Economic Way of Thinking" and was one of the legendary teachers of economics in United States. I loved this lecture which happens to be his last public lecture and was delivered on given February 17, 2000 in Seattle.

In this lecture he talks about the moral criticisms of capitalism or as he would prefer to say 'market-coordinated' system. As a person who came to the field of economics from theology, he indeed has interesting perspectives on the morality of free market system. Previously an ardent Marxist, Haynes started reading economics when his friends suggested him that he might be on the right track by criticizing capitalism but it would help him if he studied some economics as well. He says later on he found  that 'almost all of the moral criticisms of capitalism that he had been triumphantly parading around in the seminary campus were misunderstandings'. He argues that capitalism evolves naturally and competition is an inevitable thing as long (Read forever) as there is scarcity.

He also says that there, however, is a very valid moral criticism of capitalism that is often forgotten by the moral critics. Capitalism subverts community which almost every one of us are fond of. He suggests people to find ways to nurture community without destroying the market so that we can get the best of both worlds.

You can listen to the lecture here:
So what do you think? Feel free to post your comments below: